February 21, 2009
Baha'i Anxiety: Sects and Vile Hints in Iran
Several leaders in the Baha'i faith -- that other other other other Abrahamic monotheism -- have been charged in Iran with espionage and other crimes, with possible death penalty exposure. These were generally seen as pretext charges for a broad official chronic program of persecution. The charges are regarded as probable pretext most especially because Baha'i have little access to secrets, being denied official employment, and also because the alleged country of espionagery, Israel, is naturally going to have relatively extensive ties with the Baha'i leaders because the city of Haifa, Israel is the site of the Baha'i Vatican. The Baha'i world headquarters have been situated there because that religion's founding family settled there in early 20th century Palestine around the time of the British Mandate's start, and after exile from Iran/Persia where they and the faith had originated.
Posted by Matthew Hogan at February 21, 2009 08:57 AM
Filed Under: Central Asia
, Gulf
, Islam & Politics
, Religious Minorities
, Society & Culture
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.aqoul.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/3801
Comments
If I’ve managed to follow your logical leaps correctly probable pretext tied in with little access means that it continues to be possible to justify vile hints against those pesky other other other others whose preference tends towards a new and kinder, gentler version of al insan al kamil.
No actual condemnation of the Iranian government on your part, but res ipsa loquiter, I suppose.
Posted by: Ahem at February 23, 2009 01:11 AM
If I’ve managed to follow your logical leaps correctly probable pretext tied in with little access means that it continues to be possible to justify vile hints against those pesky other other other others whose preference tends towards a new and kinder, gentler version of al insan al kamil.
No actual condemnation of the Iranian government on your part, but res ipsa loquiter, I suppose.
Posted by: Ahem at February 23, 2009 01:12 AM
And your home planet is what now?
Posted by: matthew hogan at February 23, 2009 09:24 AM
As always, planet Earth. You should try paying us a visit sometime.
Posted by: Ahem at February 23, 2009 05:28 PM
Is that the Earth where the principle Res Ipsa Loquitur has become res ipsa loquiter?
"People called Romanes, they go the 'ouse?"
Posted by: matthew hogan at February 23, 2009 07:57 PM
I am often surprised that the Baha'i exist at all in Iran, it seems like the entire faith, which directly claim that the Bahaullah was the Mahdi, should, if no other faith, be stamped out by the Muslims, most of the by the Shia. I mean, if there were ever heretics within Islam, the Baha'i certianly are no?
To be clear, I don't beleive that there is anything actually wrong with their religion and I certainly don't beleive that they should be harrassed, let along /killed/ because of it. I am just saying, it seems like it would be enemy number 1 someone thats actually looking for an enemy.
Anyway, I have a question for the more knowledgeable people here. As far as I understand it, in Iran, there are the Bah'ai and the Babis, with the Babis being those follwers of the Bab who did /not/, ultimately, support Bahaullah, who claimed to be the fulfillment of what the Bab spoke about (or something along those lines). When we see about crackdowns on the Baha'i in Iran, can we also assume that the Baibs are also being cracked down upon? Or are they so few as to escape focus?
Forgive my ignorance on such matters if it has come up in the above.
Posted by: nygdan at February 26, 2009 10:26 AM
As a share of the total Iranian population, the Bahais are a tiny tiny minority. This, in conjunction with their commitment for keeping their heads down politically and organizationally explain the de facto tolerance. There's also the issue of UN pressure, which is not as insignificant as most presume. The UN special rapporteur for human rights occasionally reports on the Bahai issue and often the Iranian government decides that the minimal gains of scapegoating the Bahais is usually not worth the negative attention and pressure such actions bring. With westerners threatening ever stronger sanctions and the US threatening war, why give them another excuse? Why make it easier for Iran-hawks to sell their agenda by invoking blatant human rights abuses(as was done over Saddam's treatment of his minorities)?
This is not to say that there hasn't been large-scale attempts to get rid of the Bahais. There was a lot of violent repression when the religion first appeared in the mid-1800s. It spread extremely rapidly in the beginning, similar to Quakerism, and thousands were slaughtered. After the 1979 Revolution, there was another, albeit smaller, round of repression back when the ayatollahs were busy destroying the many competing organizations(the leftists were far more important in this regard and were hit a lot harder).
The Babis are a dramatically smaller group than the Bahis and so under the radar even more so. Neither are a real threat and so neither are worth the effort of eradicating.
Posted by: Djuha at March 1, 2009 03:41 PM
While we certainly deplore the abuse and injustices of Iranian authorities towards Baha'is in that Nation, we consider that readers should be informed that The National Spiritual Assembly of Bahá'ís of the United States is acting with a similar attitude and plans towards Orthodox Baha'is in America as the attitude and plans of Iranian authorities towards Baha'is who live in that Nation. The National Spiritual Assembly of Baha'is of the United States is attempting to use U.S. Courts to force Orthodox Baha'is to stop practicing their Faith, stopping them from identifying themselves as Baha'is or using the name Baha'i or the symbols of their Faith. The National Spiritual Assembly
failed in its Court Action to deprive Orthodox Baha'is of their freedom of religion and now the National Spiritual Assembly filed an appeal to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals of Judge Amy J. St. Eve's decision in favor of the Orthodox Baha'i Faith. Here is the link which leads to the details of the Court Action: http://www.truebahai.com/court_case.html
Evidently the goal/plan of the leadership of the large body of Baha'is concerning Orthodox Baha'is parallels the goal/plan of Islamic leaders in Iran towards Baha'is, namely to eradicate them, and the justification of the leadership of the large body of Baha'is for its actions against Orthodox Baha'is is identical, namely, that it considers Orthodox Baha'is to be apostates (heretical/Covenant-breakers).
Posted by: Ross Campbell at March 22, 2009 01:47 PM
Is that the group that doesn't agree with the Shoghi Effendi succession?
This tactic seems something like the use of copyright laws to prevent Ahmadis from self-identifying as Muslims in Pakistan.
Posted by: matthew hogan at March 22, 2009 03:37 PM

RSS



